Beasley Firm attorney Louis F. Tumolo won a $15 million wrongful death verdict in Chester County on October 26, 2026, for the family of a man who died after doctors at Phoenixville Hospital failed to diagnose and treat a heart valve infection. The verdict came in a retrial, after the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed an earlier defense verdict.
The case involves Robert Kline and the failure to diagnose endocarditis on his aortic valve during a hospital admission in January 2018. During trial, Mr. Tumolo presented evidence that Mr. Kline’s cardiologist failed to recognize signs of endocarditis early during the hospital admission. The cardiologist ordered a cardiac catheterization, including left heart catheterization and left ventriculogram, which are contraindicated in patients with endocarditis. To perform the catheterization, the physician must cross the aortic valve. When the infected aortic valve was crossed, vegetations were dislodged and embolized to Mr. Kline’s brain causing multiple strokes. Mr. Kline experienced neurological changes, never returned to his baseline mental status and died in the hospital five days later.
After six days of trial, the jury returned a $15 million dollar award, with $5 million in wrongful death damages and $10 million in survival action damages. Wrongful death damages compensate the family for what they lost because of Mr. Kline’s death, while survival action damages compensate his estate for the pain and suffering Mr. Kline experienced before his death.
The retrial was the result of a ruling near the conclusion of the first trial in December 2023. After all parties rested their cases, and only minutes before closing arguments, the defense made a motion arguing that plaintiff’s claim that the hospital was vicariously liable for the care of the cardiologist who recommended the catheterization did not match the complaint, because the cardiologist had not been individually named as a defendant. The trial court granted the motion, and the jury returned a defense verdict without ever deciding whether the hospital was responsible for the cardiologists care. The Beasley Firm appealed and in March 2025, the Superior Court reversed and remanded the case for a new trial.
For the Kline family, that meant a post-trial motion, an appeal, and a second trial, because the firm believed a jury should decide every claim they had. It is the same commitment that has helped our clients recover more than $2 billion since 1958. If you have lost a loved one to medical negligence, our wrongful death attorneys will fight for your family at every stage. Call (215) 866-2424 or contact us for a free case evaluation.

Disclaimer: The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.